Should I reattempt CAT?: A Detailed Analysis

Should I reattempt CAT?: A Detailed Analysis


​​The CAT results are out, and the air is thick with a mix of relief and anxiety. You check your CAT score, while a wave of disappointment washes over you. It wasn't what you'd hoped for. The dream of a top-tier MBA, now a distant possibility, feels like a mirage. You're left with a nagging question: should I retake CAT?

Don't worry, you're not alone. Many of us are in the same boat, staring at our scores with a mixture of confusion and doubt. The pressure is real, the future feels uncertain. Should you push yourself through another year of intense preparation, or explore alternative paths?

It's a tough decision, one that weighs heavy on our hearts and minds. But remember, this isn't the end. It's just a twist in the journey. Take a deep breath, analyze your situation, and remember “Picture abhi baaki hai mere dost” 

Feeling lost about how to decide? Don't worry, you're in the right place! We're here to give you the clarity and insights you need to make a smart decision about your career path. By the end of this blog, you'll have a clear understanding of your options and the confidence to choose the best path forward.

Understanding Your "Why": The Foundation of Your Decision

Before diving into specific scenarios, it's vital to define your "why" – your core motivation for pursuing an MBA. This will act as a compass, guiding your decision-making process.

1. Career Advancement:

  • The Goal: You want to climb the corporate ladder, take on leadership roles, and potentially even reach the C-suite.
  • The MBA's Role: An MBA, especially from a top-tier institute, provides the credibility, networking opportunities, and strategic skills to excel in senior management positions. It's a powerful signal that you're serious about your career and ready to take on significant responsibilities.
  • Retake CAT? If your dream career path is heavily dependent on a top-tier MBA, retaking CAT might be worth the effort. However, also consider if there are other ways to achieve your goals, like targeted certifications or acquiring specific skills.

2. Industry Shift:

  • The Goal: You want to move from one industry to another, maybe even one completely unrelated to your current field.
  • The MBA's Role: An MBA provides a foundation of business knowledge, regardless of the industry. It also offers a chance to network with professionals from diverse backgrounds and learn about different industries. This exposure can help you confidently navigate a new career path.
  • Retake CAT? If the industry shift is crucial to your long-term happiness and career fulfillment, and a top-tier MBA can significantly boost your chances, then a retake might be worthwhile.

3. Entrepreneurial Dreams:

  • The Goal: You want to start your own business, take control of your career, and build something from scratch.
  • The MBA's Role: An MBA provides a comprehensive understanding of business fundamentals, including finance, marketing, strategy, and operations. It also helps develop essential skills for managing resources, building teams, and navigating the complexities of running a business.
  • Retake CAT? A top-tier MBA can provide valuable contacts and resources for budding entrepreneurs. But weigh it against the time and cost. If you're confident in your business idea and can learn the basics on your own, maybe the MBA can wait.

4. Knowledge Enhancement:

  • The Goal: You want to deepen your understanding of business principles, develop critical thinking skills, and expand your analytical capabilities.
  • The MBA's Role: An MBA offers a rigorous academic experience that challenges your thinking, provides a holistic view of business, and prepares you for complex decision-making.
  • Retake CAT? If your main goal is to gain a deeper understanding of business, consider other options like executive education programs or specialized certifications. An MBA is a big commitment, but if your desire for knowledge is strong, it might be worth the effort.

5. Personal Growth:

  • The Goal: You want to become a better leader, develop your communication and negotiation skills, expand your network, and ultimately become a more confident and effective individual.
  • The MBA's Role: The MBA experience fosters personal growth through demanding coursework, challenging group projects, and interaction with diverse individuals. You learn from experienced professors, industry leaders, and your peers, developing both hard and soft skills that prepare you for leadership roles.
  • Retake CAT? If personal growth is your primary motivation, consider if an MBA is the only way to achieve this. Leadership development programs, mentoring, and taking on challenging roles in your current company can also contribute to personal growth.

Evaluating Your Profile: Strengths and Weaknesses

Once you've defined your motivation, it's time to assess your profile, recognizing both your strengths and weaknesses. This self-awareness will help you determine whether a retake is a strategically sound move.


  • Strong Academic Record: A solid academic foundation is a significant advantage, especially if you believe your CAT score didn't reflect your true potential.
  • Work Experience: Work experience, particularly in a relevant field, adds immense value to your profile and increases your chances of admission to top programs.
  • Extracurricular Activities: Demonstrating leadership and teamwork through extracurricular activities showcases a well-rounded personality and enhances your candidacy.
  • Prior CAT Preparation: You remember the feeling, right? The hours spent hunched over textbooks, the countless practice tests, the adrenaline rush of the exam itself. You poured your heart and soul into the CAT, building a strong set of knowledge and skills. Then, the dreaded "Game Over" screen. You were back to square one, disheartened and unsure.
  • But hold on. This isn't just any ordinary "Game Over." This time, when you respawn, you don't lose your progress. You've got it all: the strategies, the shortcuts, the mental muscle you've built. It's like being reborn with the wisdom of your past life, ready to conquer the challenge with a fierce, almost supernatural advantage. You're not starting from scratch; you're starting from "Level Max." And that, my friend, changes everything.


  • Low CAT Percentile: A significantly lower-than-target CAT score is a major hurdle that needs to be addressed.
  • Limited Work Experience: If you're a fresher with limited work experience, it can be a challenge in securing a coveted MBA seat.
  • Weak Academic Record: A weak academic record might necessitate a strategic approach to profile building before retaking CAT.
  • Financial Constraints: Limited financial resources can pose a significant barrier to retaking CAT and pursuing an MBA.

Analyzing the Opportunities and Threats:

Retaking CAT opens up opportunities but also presents potential threats that need careful consideration.


  • Improved Score: With focused preparation and strategic planning, you can significantly improve your CAT score in the next attempt.
  • Profile Enhancement: Utilize the gap year to gain relevant work experience, pursue certifications, volunteer, or engage in internships to strengthen your profile.
  • Evolving Job Market: The job market is constantly changing. Retaking CAT could open doors to new opportunities that weren't available before.
  • Increased Confidence: A successful retake can boost your confidence and motivate you to strive for your MBA goals.


  • Time Constraint: Retaking CAT might delay your career progress and impact your earnings potential.
  • Competitive Pressure: The competition for MBA seats is fierce, and a retake doesn't guarantee success.
  • Changing Personal Circumstances: Life can throw curveballs. Unexpected events might disrupt your preparation or change your priorities.
  • Financial Burden: The cost of preparation and potential lost income can add significant financial strain.

Decision-Making Framework: Weighing the Costs and Benefits

CAT results are in, and your heart sinks as you see the score. It's not what you were hoping for, and the dream of a top-tier MBA suddenly feels a lot more distant. The question hangs heavy in the air: Should I retake CAT?

It's a tough call, a crossroads where logic battles with ambition. On one hand, you have the experience of a year of dedicated preparation; you've learned the ropes, you've faced the challenge. On the other hand, there's the pressure of time, the financial implications, and the ever-present worry of what-if.

Still not sure how to decide? Let's break down the decision-making process using the tried-and-true SWOT analysis framework. Check which category you fall into below and see how the SWOT analysis can help you weigh your options.

You've got a job, you've already taken the CAT multiple times, and you're starting to feel the weight of repeated attempts.

Scenario 1: The Experienced Professional

  • Strengths: You've already got valuable work experience, and you understand the CAT like the back of your hand.
  • Weaknesses: Multiple attempts might indicate a need to refine your study approach or address specific areas of weakness.
  • Opportunities: You can use this knowledge to strategize your preparation, focus on your weaknesses, and aim for a significant score improvement.
  • Threats: The time investment and financial cost of retaking the CAT might be substantial, especially if you're happy with your current job.

Decision: If your passion for an MBA burns bright and you're confident in your ability to improve your score, then retaking CAT might be worthwhile. However, if your current career path is fulfilling and the opportunity cost is significant, consider exploring alternative routes to career advancement.

Scenario 2: The Fresh Graduate

You're just a fresh graduate starting out with your career, and the weight of your first CAT score feels overwhelming.

  • Strengths: You've got age on your side, ample time to gain work experience, and a fresh perspective on your career goals.
  • Weaknesses: Lack of work experience might be a disadvantage during the MBA admissions process.
  • Opportunities: Focus on building a strong profile by gaining relevant work experience, pursuing certifications, and sharpening your skills for the next CAT attempt.
  • Threats: Delaying your career entry might feel like a setback, but the benefits of a top-tier MBA could significantly outweigh the perceived downside.

Decision: Gaining work experience before retaking the CAT is generally recommended. It will strengthen your profile, give you a better understanding of your career aspirations, and provide a solid foundation for your MBA journey.

Scenario 3: The Gap Year Warrior

You dedicated a year to solely focus on CAT preparation, and now the pressure is on.

  • Strengths: You've got the time and resources to focus exclusively on CAT preparation and improvement.
  • Weaknesses: The opportunity cost of a gap year, including lost income and potential work experience, is significant.
  • Opportunities: You can leverage your dedicated preparation to significantly improve your score and enhance your chances of admission.
  • Threats: If you haven't achieved your target score despite a year of preparation, the pressure to make a decision can be intense.

Decision: If you believe in your ability to significantly improve your score and you're confident in your preparation strategy, then retaking the CAT is a reasonable option. If you've exhausted your preparation potential or are starting to feel burnt out, it's time to explore alternative paths, like enrolling in a lower-ranked program or pursuing a different career path.

Scenario 4: The Driven Dreamer

You're passionate about an MBA and believe you can achieve your desired score with dedicated effort.

  • Strengths: You have the motivation and dedication to persevere through intense preparation.
  • Weaknesses: You might face financial constraints or pressure to start earning immediately.
  • Opportunities: Utilize the time to develop your profile, gain relevant experience, and refine your understanding of the MBA landscape.
  • Threats: The time investment and the possibility of failing again can be daunting.

Decision: If your passion is strong and you're confident in your abilities, then retaking CAT is a worthwhile investment. Remember to create a backup plan in case your score doesn't meet your expectations.

Remember: The decision to retake the CAT is a personal one, and there's no right or wrong answer. Take the time to reflect on your goals, your strengths, and your resources. It's a journey, not a race, and the right path will lead you to where you're meant to be.

Beyond Scores: The Importance of Holistic Profile Building

Retaking CAT is just one piece of the puzzle. Remember, MBA admissions are holistic, considering your academic achievements, work experience, extracurricular activities, and your overall personality.

Want to level up your MBA application? We've got you covered! Get ready for a deep dive into profile building - we're sharing expert tips and strategies to bridge the gap between your current skillset and your dream MBA. Stay tuned for more insights coming soon!

How to bridge Skill Gap


The decision to retake CAT is deeply personal and requires careful analysis of your unique situation, goals, and aspirations. This framework provides a structured approach to help you make an informed decision, weighing the costs and benefits and considering the broader context of your MBA journey.

Remember, there's no right or wrong answer. It's about finding the path that aligns with your aspirations and leads you towards fulfilling your ambitions.